JUDGMENT

It is a sad fact that we do not hesitate to judge each other. This usually happens quickly and with little or no evidence to support our conclusions. We form unfounded opinions based on nothing more than how someone looks, the way they move or the way they talk.

None of those things tell us anything important about the person, and yet we accept or reject individuals constantly based on our immediate response to their physical presence. It is completely unfair to the people we are so eager to judge, and we also cheat ourselves out of the opportunity to get to know many interesting people who could eventually become very important in our lives.

This is particularly true when it comes to the way the public sometimes reacts to individuals with developmental disabilities. Thankfully, many people accept those whose appearance or behavior may seem different in some way. They are tolerant and respectful, and they do not judge those they do not know.

This is how it should be.

Unfortunately, others are not so enlightened. They immediately decide they want nothing to do with a person they perceive as not being their equal.

Each one of us is convinced that we are important and that we have something unique to offer to the world. We believe that we matter, that we are relevant and that we are irreplaceable – and we are right. 

But some do not believe that is true for people with intellectual challenges. Because their physical appearance, underdeveloped social skills, challenges with their speech or mobility issues can make them stand out from the crowd, they are shunned by those who will not make the effort to get to know them.

For many people, meeting someone with a developmental disability makes them rush to judgment based on nothing more than a brief exchange that does not allow them the opportunity to interact with that individual on a meaningful level.

An example would be encountering a young adult with Down syndrome who is dealing with significant hearing loss which makes it difficult for him to control the volume of his voice.

Let’s suppose that Robert goes to a nice restaurant with his mother. After being seated, he becomes very excited as he looks over all the choices on the menu. His voice rises to a level that draws the attention of those at surrounding tables. His mother does her best to remind him that they are inside a public place and therefore he should lower his voice, but it is no use. Robert is so happy to be eating out that her admonitions go unheeded.

In this situation, there would probably be a variety of reactions from the other diners. Some would feel uneasy and wish that the host had seated him farther away. Some, without even realizing it, would stare at his table and wonder what is wrong with him. Others might feel sorry for his mother because, from their point of view, she has the burden of caring for him her entire life. In each case, they would have formed an opinion about Robert without knowing anything about him as a person.

For those who felt uncomfortable in the restaurant and rushed to judgment, it would benefit them to stop and carefully consider their inappropriate reactions. What made them feel the way they did?  Was it unfamiliarity? Have they never been around an individual with Down syndrome? Do they not personally know anyone with a developmental disability? Or is it something more unpleasant, such as believing that some lives have less meaning.

Fortunately, there would be others in the restaurant that would see a person who was obviously overjoyed to be dining out. They would see his unrestrained excitement over the available food choices. They would see someone who was loved by a caring parent and who returned that affection without hesitation. They would see two people who were happy to be out of the house and enjoying each other’s company. They might wonder if they were there to celebrate a special occasion such as a birthday.

These people would avoid jumping to conclusions about Robert as a person, and they would simply accept the situation for what it was; two human beings engaging in one of the normal activities in society that we all enjoy.

Judgment is wrong because it hurts both the innocent person it’s directed at and also the person who engages in such limited and shallow thinking. When we judge someone who has an intellectual challenge, without really knowing them, it serves no worthwhile purpose. It only reinforces stereotypes that people have fought against all their lives while adding insensitivity and intolerance to the world. This type of judgment is morally unjust because it fosters a lack of respect for those who have done nothing to deserve such treatment.

On the other hand, when you meet someone who has a developmental disability, they are usually more than willing to accept you just the way you are. They are far less likely to judge you on a superficial level, and most of the time they see you as a potential friend. The world would be a far more compassionate place if we’d take this approach with each person we encounter.

Every one of us can learn a great lesson from the people that society is so quick to dismiss if we will just keep an open mind and make the effort to accept others without judgment.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s